Marcus Allen – Los Angeles Raiders
He’s a player often labeled as one of the most overrated in the hallowed Halls of Canton. This running back experienced his apex in 1985, unleashing a beastly performance in Super Bowl XVIII that etched his name in football history. His unforgettable feat included running an astounding 191 yards, catching two passes for 18 yards, and scoring two touchdowns. During the golden stretch of 1983 to 1985, he consistently surpassed the 1,000-yard mark.
In the realm of running backs, he displayed an uncommon longevity, enduring for an impressive 16 seasons in the NFL. Accumulating over 12,000 rushing yards and 5,000 receiving yards in his career is no small feat. However, the contention persists that he falls short of the lofty ranks reserved for the game’s most revered players, primarily because he had just a solitary season in which he truly stood out.