Roger Wehrli – St. Louis Cardinals
In stark contrast to Owens, Wehrli remained loyal to a single team throughout his entire career. For 14 years, from 1968 to 1982, he displayed unwavering consistency, though not necessarily exceptional brilliance. While he secured his place in the Hall of Fame in 2007, it sometimes appears as though he landed there by default, with no more deserving candidate in sight.
Notching 40 interceptions is a commendable feat, yet the fact that he achieved it over a lengthy 14-season span dilutes the overall impressiveness. As a speedy cornerback, he embodied the safe, dependable choice for teams. But the looming question remains: Does being a reliable player make him Hall of Fame material?